Two good shingles. One right for you.
Eleven head-to-head comparisons across the seven major asphalt shingle brands. Every page has the same shape: a draggable visual comparison at the top, a spec table with real numbers in every cell, a decision rubric, install pricing context from Florida contractors, and verified quotes from r/Roofing. Sorted by search popularity so the highest-interest comparisons surface first.
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Two mid-tier architectural shingles within a few dollars of each other at retail. Atlas Pinnacle Pristine ships in the larger HP42 format with 3M Scotchgard streak-fighter granules baked in at the factory. GAF Timberline…
Read the comparison → ComparisonCertainTeed Grand Manor vs IKO Royal Estate
Two designer-tier asphalt shingles built to mimic the look of natural cedar shake or slate at a fraction of the cost. CertainTeed Grand Manor is a triple-layer laminate with Class 4 impact rating as standard and one of t…
Read the comparison → ComparisonCertainTeed Landmark vs GAF Timberline HDZ
CertainTeed Landmark is the heavier of the two and carries the longest algae warranty in its base spec. GAF Timberline HDZ is lighter, easier to install with the wide StrikeZone nailing area, and offers WindProven unlimi…
Read the comparison → ComparisonCertainTeed Landmark vs CertainTeed Landmark Pro
Landmark Pro is the upgrade tier of the Landmark family. It is roughly 40 pounds per square heavier (270 vs 230 lbs), carries a longer algae warranty (30 vs 25 years), and unlocks the Max Def color palette with richer, m…
Read the comparison → ComparisonGAF Timberline HDZ vs Owens Corning Duration
GAF Timberline HDZ leads on the WindProven unlimited wind warranty, color count, and install speed. Owens Corning Duration leads on the SureNail triple-layer nailing strip and a heavier feel that some contractors prefer.…
Read the comparison → ComparisonGAF Timberline UHDZ vs CertainTeed Landmark Pro
The premium upgrade tier of the two most-installed shingle lines in the country. GAF Timberline UHDZ adds the UltraMat fiberglass core to qualify for UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating and the 30-year StainGuard Plus PRO alga…
Read the comparison → ComparisonIKO Cambridge vs GAF Timberline HDZ
IKO Cambridge is the budget-friendly option, running 10 to 20 percent cheaper than GAF Timberline HDZ at retail. GAF wins on virtually every spec category: longer algae warranty, longer material warranty, stronger wind w…
Read the comparison → ComparisonMalarkey Legacy vs Owens Corning Duration
Two premium architectural shingles built around different engineering philosophies. Malarkey Legacy uses NEX polymer-modified asphalt that stays flexible across a wider temperature range, paired with 3M Scotchgard streak…
Read the comparison → ComparisonMalarkey Vista AR vs GAF Timberline HDZ
Malarkey Vista uses NEX polymer-modified (rubberized) asphalt for Class 4 impact resistance baked into the standard product, plus 3M Smog-Reducing Granules and significant recycled content. GAF Timberline HDZ uses conven…
Read the comparison → ComparisonOwens Corning Duration vs CertainTeed Landmark
Both shingles are mid-tier architectural products from top-three manufacturers. Owens Corning Duration leads on the SureNail triple-layer nailing strip, a wider 600 percent nail zone, and the TruDefinition color contrast…
Read the comparison → ComparisonOwens Corning Duration vs Owens Corning Duration Designer
Duration Designer is the aesthetic upgrade tier of the Duration platform. Same SureNail nailing strip, same 130 mph wind rating, same StreakGuard algae coverage, same lifetime limited warranty. The differences are color …
Read the comparison → ComparisonTAMKO Heritage vs IKO Cambridge
The two most common entry-level architectural shingles on the budget end of the market. TAMKO Heritage is American-made (Joplin, Missouri) with a Limited Lifetime warranty and the Algae Cleaning Track granule blend. IKO …
Read the comparison →